The Gatsby House was great! We really missed not having a pool for the young ones but the house was very comfortable and had every thing we could have asked for. The linens were top notch and having them on them beds ahead of our arrival was wonderful!

The Gatsby House was by far the best rental property for my family. We are a large family of children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren. We were thrilled that each family group had their own bedroom. The layout of the house provided us with space to enjoy group time as well as personal time. The children loved the games. The decor of the house was beautiful and made for a relaxing atmosphere. We certainly recommend the property and look forward to a repeat visit. Thank you Sea Star Reality for a wonderful vacation.

The house was absolutely beautiful! Very spacious and decorated beautifully. The only thing I never encountered was having to buy toilet paper, garbage bags detergent & dish washing tablets for the dishwasher. Other than that the house was beautiful.

This house was so unique and such a wonderful stay with plenty of rooms to sleep in and enjoy. The beds were comfortable. The cleanliness was top-tier! We will definitely stay there again. If you are looking for a wonderful beach house with a lot of character, this is what you are looking for!

The Gatsby House is such an awesome home to stay in for both adults and children! We hosted a competition dance team retreat for minis and juniors and everyone had a blast! The home included everything you could possibly need and then some. The location is perfect, close to all the amazing things Garden City has to offer but not right on top of it, the beach is just a few steps away or if you're more of a marsh person, that is also just a short walk away! We will be staying at The Gatsby House again!

This house had it all. The beach is just steps away. House has everything you could need and plenty of space. We enjoyed our getaway and highly recommend this house.